Vosenna -
I recommend the HP Color LaserJet series of printers because they typically outperform just about everything else that I've tested. I've used a wide variety of different laser printer models over the years, and the HP Color LaserJet printers are almost always the top performing printers with our weatherproof laser materials. They are very positively reviewed by customers who have used our label materials with them as well.
It's difficult to compare a monochrome laser printer to a color laser printer because they serve entirely different purposes. Monochrome laser printers are usually intended for use as high-volume document printers, focused primarily on providing legible text and fast printing. They're not known for high-resolution imaging, and printing photos or graphics using a monochrome laser printer may result in below average print quality.
With all of that being said, your best bet in the short term may be an inkjet printer due to the upfront cost of getting started with high-quality color laser printer. In the long run printing with a laser printer is probably more economical in terms cost per sheet, but the initial cost of the printers and toner cartridges are typically considerably higher compared to desktop inkjet printers.
Recently, I've had a lot of success using the Canon PIXMA TS9120 printer with our weatherproof inkjet materials. The printer came highly recommended in our printer feedback surveys, and seems to be reviewed well across the internet as well. I've extensively tested both of our weatherproof inkjet materials (
Weatherproof White Matte and
Weatherproof White Gloss) with this printer model and have been very pleased with the results.
It's important to note that our clear materials for inkjet printing are not weatherproof or moisture resistant. If you need a clear label that will hold up to direct contact with moisture you should consider a color laser printer rather than an inkjet printer.
I know you're resistant to the HP brand, but based on your requirements and the feedback we've received the HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP M180nw may be a good choice for you. It's an All-In-One color laser printer that is currently available from HP. I haven't had the opportunity to use this specific printer model yet, but the feedback from our customers is positive and the reviews I'm able to locate online appear to be very positive as well. Of the laser printers that I have used, both the HP Color LaserJet Pro M252dw and HP Color LaserJet Pro M452dn have performed incredibly well with all of our weatherproof laser materials.
I hope this helps. If you need any additional information please just let us know.